Friday, 14 August 2015

Poly Closure: Personal Views

The issue in the air in as far as tertiary education in the country is concerned is that of the closure of the Polytechnic; a constituent college of the University of Malawi. There has been a lot of reaction to the issue, subjective and objective alike and I just had to give my own comment on this.

When I first heard that the Wadiyans were demonstrating just some 3 days after the arrival of continuing students my best guess was that the demonstration was money related. Everybody who is following the issue now knows that my instincts were right and the demonstrations started because of fees and upkeep allowance issues.

From what I gather, the administration wanted to deduct some money from the upkeep and redirect the same towards the payment of fees (I stand to be corrected) but that is not too important if we are to go by what this post is about. What is of the paramount importance is that the issue was about money, as I had correctly surmised upon hearing that some intellectuals had blocked the Highway.

Some might wonder as to why I immediately though of money as the etiologic agent of the demonstration. Well. It is not that much of rocket science. Pretty much every kodo kodo I have witnessed from the Polytechnic came out of money issues; be it the book allowance (popularly known as SACCO) or school fees. This, to everyone who reasons objectively should beg the questioon as to what or most importantly who is causing this whole thing. Is it the spirit of entitlement and impatience on the students part? Should the blaming finger point to the administration?

As a believer in something called contact and dialogue, I would point my blaming fingers (we always need to find someone to blame) on both the students and the administration; and for a good reason.

I will be referring to what I have heard about this situation because I believe all the others were no different. According to inside sources, when the communication was made about the fees arrangement, the students called for an audience with the administration and that was not granted till the students decided to take it to the highway. One would question the administration as to why they did not grant the much needed audience to the students and the students as to why they could not wait a little longer before taking it to the streets and ruining it for themselves.

Away from the students and the administration,  I think this problem is coming from the way we as a country are financing our tertiary education. The modifications that are coming in the payment of school fees, provision of food and accommodation and book allowances are more of a curse than a blessing and if not addressed will continue to be a breeding ground for unrest in the public colleges and universities.

People might hate me for saying this but our tertiary education is too affordable and almost free. At the same time, intellectuals are supposed to be getting an amount almost equal to the yearly fees almost every month in the name of food and accommodation and as if that is not senseless enough some people have found ways of making the process even tougher to run on both the students and administrators' end. The end result is what we are seeing now; an unnecessary overlap between issues of fees and those of accommodation and meal allowances which in the old days were in a way unrelated.

This to me beg the question as to whether we as a country prematurely made the move to privatize the provision of food and accommodation in the public universities. It also makes me wonder as to whether reverting to the old system (if at all it is possible) would make things better or just worse.

I am told that we now have the National Council of Higher Education which is "reforming" the country's higher education system. Whoever is heading that thing (council, right?) should look at this as something that needs resolving otherwise we have for long applied a temporary solution (like closing colleges as if they are some hardware shop) to a permanent problem. If the financing and fees issues are not resolved, next thing you will hear is that the College of Medicine and then Chancellor College followed by Bunda and Mzuzu University are also in the streets.

To my fellow intellectuals? Patience helps. Let us accept the reality of where we are and try to be as patient as we can. On the other hand, if it becomes too much we have the option of a peaceful demonstration which does not equal to blocking roads and disturbing innocent passers by.

Someone who was selling airtime around Ginnery Corner was affected by teargas and had an early knock off. Do you know what that meant to his personal life?

3 comments:

  1. I agree to th fact tht tertiary education z almost free in Malawi...and am in agreement with whoever z making thoz reforms of trying to privatise z. we should accept th fact tht we are a developing country (am not saying poor right..lol), and making everything free (primary school, hospitals, tertiary education..etc) is retrogressive to our development. that, to me, shud end. but while tht z true, abrupt change without any plan or knowledge of the consequences is unacceptable. they shud do a step by step change, and a clear process or procedure on how things will b like, not as vague as it is being done currently. coming to the poly issue, allow me to be a student...coz Yeaah am a student!!....amati za kaisala zipite kwa kaisala...za chakudya nazo zipite ku chakudya. thts hw best I cn put t. whr do thy thnk food will come from...is th government stupid to giv us money for food and accommodation and not money for fees?...if they refuse to come and reason with the students, should we not say they wanted all this? Am tempted to say that this z a deliberate move by th administration hence the government. its better for them to just say that we not opening school soon because we currently don't have money to sustain the college, than puting the blame on students through their deep political machinations. in today's language we say "it sucks big time"..lol. I think we dnt hv leaders. everythng z jst functioning on "autopilot''

    ReplyDelete
  2. Madala, great post. Now my 2 tambala worth on the matter, for the poly closure, I blame all the shareholders: the Malawi govt, the poly admin, the students, former unima students who took any kind of loan and never repaid and also all Malawians. The Malawi govt was not wise to introduce this Malswitch program, it has ruined students, they have become used to this hand out and it seems their future also relies on this stipend. How can a govt that already relies on donor funding , distribute money freely. The govt is spending more on students than students give back to it. And we expect the country to develop, the govt should go back to the old days, where it provided food and accommodation to students or perhaps they should consider offering these services to students who want them. Some students can operate from their homes and save themselves money, those that want or need the accommodation and food should be able to have it, but not for free, at a price. Private universities are operating like this and students are paying without going into the streets and harassing citizens. Those who want an education will make any sacrifice necessary because they know its their own future at stake. The govt has ruined citizens with its basically free services to an extent where students will choose to go home instead of making a sacrifice for their own education. And we expect these future leaders to run the country without donor funding? I don’t think so. The poly admin was wrong to open the school with virtually no money to run it and then giving students the power to choose whether to stay or not. Who does that? Who is in control here? The admin or the students. This shows a lack of passion on their part, they had 4 whole months to get ready, to source funds, to fundraise or even ask for donations if necessary. The admin benefitted from the same institution and yet doesn’t want the present generation to do the same. Someone with a passion for the school needs to take over or the school will be losing business to private institutions and foreign countries. Now, students, how can you honestly decide to go home instead of staying at school, how much do you have to fork out for transport to your respective homes, its probable more than what the admin wanted from you. And then you go riot in the highway as if that will gain you favors, That’s just ruining your reputation. What if someone wanted to donate to your school and you ended up delaying or disturbing their schedule with your highway blockade. Do you think they would still donate, We all know the answer to that. To every former unima student who took a loan and never repaid it, this is also your mess. You have fostered a culture of loan defaulting and have set a bad example for future students. Now when your offspring get to college and are chased away after a mere 3 days. Don’t complain, you started it. You are also part of the reason why MSB went bankrupt and had to be sold. Then you complained again forgetting you played a role. Don’t be surprised when Mozambique and Zambia decide to buy Malawi. To every Malawian, let us stop this everything for free culture, let us learn to stand on our own two feet and make sacrifices, future generations should be donor free and proud of us and perhaps donors themselves. Otherwise, ine nde ndithawira ku Zembo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Never expected a comment so serious when I was writing this. I think I need to share these insights somewhere else.

      Visit the site again, soldier. And don't go to Zambia.

      Delete